NYC Apartments for Rent from $4,500 to $5,000

If you’re looking to rent an apartment in this price range, chances are that you want a top-notch two- or three-bedroom in one of Manhattan’s best buildings. Lucky for you, we’ve got them all listed below. These rentals are outstanding units with too many excellent features to go into in-depth here, but suffice it to say that if you look closer, you’ll like what you’ll see. Don’t take our word for it though, see for yourself. But, if you need it, we’re always here to help.

Too many results? Narrow down your Manhattan apartment search using our Advanced New York Rental Search technology.

Neighborhood

85 John Street 85 John Street

85 John Street, Financial District

85 John Street is a classic NYC building that has all the charms of old-school New York paired with all the conveniences modern New Yorkers need. The homes inside feature expansive private terraces and high ceilings, while the building offers residents a host of popular amenities including a 24-hour concierge and doorman, state-of-the-art fitness center, an outdoor wraparound roof deck, and more. 85 John Street is located in one of the best areas of Manhattan, close to Soho, Tribeca, and Chelsea and all of the amazing shopping and dining options those neighborhoods have to offer.

i Inquire about 85 John Street

Stonehenge 58 Stonehenge 58

400 East 58th Street, Sutton Place

Stonehenge58 is a full-service building located in the lovely, quiet Manhattan neighborhood of Sutton Place. This luxury structure features renovated, spacious homes with generous layouts, working fireplaces, and classic, pre-war details. Many of the apartments inside also include windowed, eat-in kitchens that offer you the opportunity to enjoy breakfast while gazing out at stunning views of the city.

i Inquire about Stonehenge 58

Tower 67 Tower 67

145 West 67th Street, Lincoln Square

Live between Central Park and the Hudson River at Tower 67, a beautiful Upper West Side high-rise with modern finishes and a classic NYC feel. Walk into the polished marble lobby and be greeted by friendly staff ready to meet residents' needs or head into the landscaped garden where you can sit by the fountain and take in beautiful weather.

1BR apartments

from $4,900/mo

View Details »

i Inquire about Tower 67

Level Level

2 North 6th Place, Williamsburg

Experience life on the Williamsburg waterfront at Level BK, a gorgeous new rental building that has been carefully crafted to help residents' live life to the fullest in the best area of Brooklyn.

i Inquire about Level

99 Gold 99 Gold

99 Gold Street, DUMBO

Experience 99 Gold, a beautiful pre-war industrial building that won the AIA Brooklyn Design Award of Merit. This former toy factory has been transformed into spacious studio, one, and two-bedroom loft residencies, with oversized windows, original details, open kitchens, and private terraces.

1BR apartments

from $4,695/mo

View Details »

i Inquire about 99 Gold

Aro Aro

242 West 53rd Street, Midtown West

Live in one of the most innovative and luxurious new buildings in NYC at Aro, a masterful reinterpretation of the NYC skyscraper. Designed by CetraRuddy, this 60-story residential building features a beautiful white metal and glass facade that truly stands out amongst the surrounding buildings. Inside are studio, one-bedroom, two-bedroom and three-bedroom luxury rentals an four stunning penthouse residences that embody the best of NYC.

i Inquire about Aro

Nine52 Nine52

416 West 52nd Street, Hell's Kitchen

Nine52 is a beautiful brick building in the heart of Hell's Kitchen, designed to blend in with its surroundings while still remaining wholly unique. The studio to three-bedroom residences and garden duplex homes inside are the perfect place to relax, unwind, and take in the beauty of the city.

i Inquire about Nine52

The Lindley The Lindley

591 Third Avenue, Murray Hill

The Lindley is a full-service luxury building located in one of the most central and convenient locations in all of NYC. This lavish building is the perfect home for New Yorkers who are looking to be in the heart of the action but still want peace and quiet at the end of the day.

i Inquire about The Lindley

Liberty View Liberty View

99 Battery Place, Battery Park City

The Suites at Liberty View are a collection of extended stay luxury apartments in the heart of Downtown Manhattan for guests looking to stay for 30 days or more. The residential suites boast full kitchens and separate living areas, marble bathrooms stocked with fine towels and toiletries, bedrooms with fine linens, goose down pillows, and generous closets. There are flat screen TVs in each suite as well as utilities, Cable, and Wi-Fi included.

1BR apartments

from $4,500/mo

View Details »

i Inquire about Liberty View

The Rushmore The Rushmore

80 Riverside Boulevard, Lincoln Square

Make Riverside Park and the Hudson River your backyard at The Rushmore at 80 Riverside Blvd. This 42-story Upper West Side building is a prime example of UWS luxury living, featuring 271 apartments that range from studio to five-bedrooms, suiting NYC families of every size.

The lavish homes inside feature two distinct options for kitchen and bathroom finishes allowing residents to express their own style. They also include Miele, Viking, Sub-Zero, and Waterworks fixtures and spacious layouts.

i Inquire about The Rushmore

Legal Stuff!

The owner of this website is not a licensed real estate broker or representative of the buildings or apartments contained on the website. This website is strictly for informational purposes. There are no property listings on this website. Nothing contained on this website shall suggest the availability of a property or guarantee the accuracy of accompanying prices.

If you would like more information about a property, we will connect you with a real estate broker who will be able to give you more information about available apartments and schedule a showing.

Luxury Rentals Manhattan

Rental Guides

Green Rental Apartments

No Fee Apartments

Hot Rental Searches

Buildings by Street

NYC Apartments for Rent Near Subway Lines

NYC Apartments for Rent from $4,500 to $5,000